Stardew Valley Trophy Unforgettable Soup
How to Unlock the Unforgettable Soup Trophy in Stardew
In order to unlock the Unforgettable Soup trophy in Stardew Valley, you’ll first need to complete the Luau event - and not just complete it, but also do so to such a standard that you wow the visiting Governor, who is playing a visit to Pelican Town for the occasion. This depends on the type of ingredients that you add to the potluck soup, so making sure you have contributed quality products is critical.
Make Your Own Stardew Valley Server
Along a similar line of thought, it’s not only important to make sure the crops you’re growing in Stardew Valley are of a high quality, but also your server as a whole. Luckily, with ScalaCube’s premium Stardew servers, you can enjoy exceptional uptime for a lag-free experience, no matter how often you choose to play.
What to Bring to the Luau in Stardew to Unlock the Unforgettable Soup Trophy
At this point, we’ve briefly considered the importance of contributing high-quality ingredients to the Luau potluck in Stardew Valley. But what sort of ingredients should you be looking to bring along? Well, when attending the Stardew Valley Luau, there are several “best items” you might want to contribute to the soup that will help you achieve the Unforgettable Soup trophy. A few of these include the following:- A wide range of fruit wines and pale ale
- Starfruits or starfruit products
- Large goat milk (silver quality or greater) or regular goat milk (gold or iridium quality)
- Smoked fish
- Gold or iridium grade truffles
- Certain gold or iridium grade crops (such as melons and yams)
It’s worth noting, given the above brief list, that the first qualifying item you’ll likely get hold of in the game is either silver quality goat’s cheese or large goat milk. However, you may be able to make plenty of silver quality wines that could also contribute to the potluck with excellent results.

The general rule of thumb when looking at the different types of products you can contribute to the Luau potluck is that products should be of a high star quality and ideally an artisan product. Truffles, mayonnaise, goat’s milk, goat’s cheese, wine, ostrich eggs, and the like are all prime examples of this.
What Stardew Valley Luau Ingredients Are Not the Best Items to Bring?
Thus far, we’ve outlined some of the most common types of premium ingredients that can help you achieve the best possible result in the Stardew Luau. However, you might now be wondering: what sort of Stardew Valley Luau ingredients are not suitable to add to the potluck? Well, basic ingredients (such as regular chicken eggs and regular cow milk) will not be suitable, nor will any normal quality items.The majority of crops will also be unsuitable for making the best possible “unforgettable soup.” For example, many fruits are not good enough to contribute unless fermented into wine first.
Is There a Benefit to Creating Quality Stardew Valley Luau Soup?
Creating the best possible quality Luau soup offers a couple of noteworthy benefits. Of course, this unlocks the Unforgettable Soup achievement, which is nice in itself. However, this also provides a massive friendship boost with many villagers, making it an efficient way to work on your friendship with the game’s many NPCs.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I buy the Governor’s Hat after completing the Luau?
If you’ve completed the Luau in Stardew Valley with an ingredient that makes for a delicious soup, you’ll complete the Unforgettable Soup achievement. After this, a replica of the Governor’s Hat can be purchased from the Hat Mouse at the old abandoned house.
Why did my friends and I get a “missing something” response to the Luau in Stardew Valley?
If you are playing a multiplayer game in Stardew Valley, every player will need to contribute a high-quality item to the Luau potluck. If not, the “it’s missing something” response will display, even if other players contributed high-quality items.
Will any high-quality ingredient be enough to create an unforgettable soup at the Luau in Stardew Valley?
No. While any high quality ingredient can be contributed to the potluck at the Stardew Valley Luau, only a select range of ingredients will be suitable to create an “Unforgettable Soup.” These largely include Smoked fish, as well as a handful of other ingredient types.